Tuesday, February 02, 2010

He's Back

Child Trafficking in Haiti
Karl Penhaul reported the details of the Baptist missionaries who have been arrested for child trafficking in Haiti. Most of the story was relayed to Penhaul by the group's translators but he also spoke directly to the 10 Americans late in the day on Tuesday.
Anderson raised a good point during his questioning of Penhaul. He said 'Clearly, anyone who is operating in Haiti, whose interested in kids or helping kids, at this point....or even that point last week, would have known or should have known that there were some very strict rules for how you go about helping kids in Haiti.'Dan Simon was in Meridian, Idaho where the Baptist missionary group is based and he reported the group has no experience running an orphanage, they are not registered as a non-profit, they didn't appear to have the financial ability to sustain the orphanage and they are not registered as an International adoption agency.Every time I heard this story the term 'ugly American' pops into my head. If you're not familiar with the meaning Dictionary.com defines "the Ugly American" as: Pejorative term for Americans traveling or living abroad who remain ignorant of local culture and judge everything by American standards.
I would bet those missionaries thought (and probably still think) that they were doing those kids and their families a huge favor rescuing them from a life in Haiti. But what they should have realized is that their efforts and money would have been more appreciated if they had worked to preserve the family unit and help it to succeed in Haiti.
To further bore you, I see a parallel here between those missionaries and religious groups here at home who seem to think they know what is best for all of us when it comes to gay marriage or a women's right to choose, etc. Pushing an agenda in God's name just isn't the Christianity I know.
I'm up pretty high on my soap box tonight, hope I don't hurt myself when I jump off!

Haiti's Orphans
Joe Johns reported from Haiti about the children and the government is trying to identify the 'new' orphans. Rev. Rick Frechette talked with Johns about the difference in orphans who have learned to survive on the streets over time and those that are on their own for the very first time. Those 'new' orphans are the ones that are trying to be rounded up and put into orphanages so they don't meet the fate that the rough streets of Port-au-Prince have waiting for them.

Civil Trials for Terrorists
Ed Henry and Dana Bash were live from DC reporting on the Christmas Day bomber and new information the government disclosed tonight. Henry said the bomber is talking with the FBI, who has worked very hard to establish a relationship with his family so he would be encouraged by them to talk.
Bash talked of the pressure Dems are under because President Obama wants to hold this trail and the 9/11 trials in civilian courts. They feel it's expensive and that foreign born terrorists don't deserve the same rights as US citizens.


Don't Ask, Don't Tell
Robert Gates and Admiral Mike Mullen testified before a Congressional Committee today that Congress should consider repealing the militaries' 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' policy that has been in effect since the Clinton era.
AC mentioned that over 13,000 have been discharged because of this policy and I heard it mentioned in an earlier report today that there are estimated 65,000 gays and lesbians currently serving.
David Gergen joined AC to discuss how the don't ask, don't tell policy came into being with President Clinton and who was and wasn't in favor of the doctrine.


Searching For Answers in Faith
Anderson walked the streets of Little Haiti in NYC on Tuesday night talking to residents who had lost family member in the earthquake. He then did an interview in the NYC studio with Pastor Joel Osteen and asked 'How can God let something like this happen?'. Here's the segment:

video


After a break AC was back and continued to explore religion with Osteen. I need to add that I found this to be one of the most interesting, telling and moving studio interviews that AC360 has ever aired.
video


Surprise, surprise Kiran Chetry stayed up way past her bedtime to read the 360 News and Business Bulletin. I enjoyed her way more than the reader last night who seemed a little too perky and might I say even flirty?
• A Senate committee heard a report today that another terror attack on the US in the next 6 months is 'certain'
• POTUS was in New Hampshire today pushing small business loans
• Punxsutawney Phil saw his shadow today so there will be six more weeks of winter
• MJ's doctor may be charged, related to the singer's death, in the next few days
• The Lancet is retracting it's published link between autism and vaccines

The Shot
The actual The Shot wasn't that great but I always love when the guys in the studio get in on the action. Take a look:

video




Anderson's tweets from today:


Kiran Chetry tweeted this picture of AC and Joel Ostein after the program ended.
A few more new pictures of AC in Haiti, thanks to Wonz




We received a comment on Monday that I found very moving and wanted to share with all of you. It was submitted by Mia Lopez who wanted AC and Sanjay to know how grateful she and her fellow Haitians are for CNN's coverage of the earthquake's aftermath. ~Phebe

On January 12, 2010 at 7:30pm I turned on CNN and it is the eyes of blue that touched my heart as Anderson Cooper fostered our country and stood strong wondering what the devastation of a 7.0 magnitude earthquake could cause a country already as improvised as Haiti. In the oceans of his eyes I saw rivers of tears and he captured me than.

I can go back to the moment at 9:45pm when Anderson explained that he would need someone to take over the broadcast because he was catching an 11pm flight to the Dominican Republic to be sure to make it into Haiti in the morning. I asked myself “Where did this love for Haiti come from?” I mean in this pale skinned, thin White man, stood this glowing center of hope for my people. “Why this interest, when usually the world simply turns the page when they hear the word Haiti?” But sure enough in the morning, after 10 agonizing hours of calling family and friends with no success, it was CNN who was first on the ground. Anderson Cooper, without a red cape, with no Gold S on his chest, simply an ash grey t-shirt which somehow symbolized the grayness of the country shown behind him as he reported. First on the scene, like a doctor scrubbing into surgery, Anderson Cooper was there. Day and night it seemed he headed our plea. He became our voice. He spoke to us, thru us and for us, so that the world would listen. He represented the majority, when in reality people were not ready to see the devastation brought to my minority.

The days turned into weeks and as his images and those of Dr. Gupta continued to ravish our minds and shake our souls, we could not just sit here and do nothing. These two gentlemen become our bulldozers, they showed us what we didn’t want to see, but should see, they told us about the stories that needed to be heard, not what was scripted by CNN Studio Producers. Larry King joined the fight as Gupta and Cooper continued everyday to devote their lives to our cause. The dynamic duo is what I called them, but it is more than super hero powers that kept them at the forefront of our minds, hearts, souls, thoughts and prayers. Sheer humanity helped those men endure for us. They automatically become the face of this terrible tragedy, the light at the end of the tunnel, knowing that we could make a difference, that we would rise above everything and Live again.

Many joke that Anderson Cooper is now an Honorary Haitian, and many would love the opportunity to shake his hand, to hug him, to invite him to dinner and to simply say THANK YOU – for not leaving us behind. Thank you for coming to our rescue, Thank you for being there when no one else was, like a best friend at a time of desperation. Thank you for caring and for being the type of person we all should strive to be.

These two men, Anderson Cooper and Dr. Sonjay Gupta will receive awards from every angle, every Haitian-American association, and they will continue to receive journalistic honors for their commitment to being the eyes and ears of an entire nation. But today, I needed to genuinely and unconditionally put finger to keyboard to say, MESI AMPIL! For reminding me that it is not my country’s title of destitute, its generalization of illiteracy or blackness, nor is it its negative view from the outside of the world’s window that matters, but it is the generosity, purity, strength and determination of my people from the inside of its throbbing heart that keeps me, my children, my parents and my family alive. Through your magic lens and your surgical prowess gentlemen, the world now knows that Haiti exists and will once again pridefully stand and prevail.






All content, unless otherwise cited, is © All Things Anderson and may not be used without consent of the blog administrator.

All Things Anderson is a blog dedicated to CNN's AC360 and its host Anderson Cooper.



video

13 comments:

judy said...

Phebe: I read the comment on the other blog from the Haitian American and found it most inspiring. I was wondering if she was in the Haitian portion of NYC when AC did his tour or was it merely coincidental.
It was good to see AC back in the studio and I have to agree with you about AC's interview with Joel. I think he too was looking for inspirational wisdom and guidance as to the reasons "why."
Also, as an aside, I don't often agree with Jon Klein, but he's right about one thing, Kiran Chetry "lights up the screen." She's beautiful!!

pebbles said...

David Gergen posted something interesting on the Live Blog. I believe Anderson, Sanjay et al deserve to get recognition on the excellent work they did in Haiti. I’m glad he shared this with us:

David Gergen February 2nd, 2010 10:45 pm ET

Hello everyone - Glad to see you here tonight - and to see Anderson home safely. I must tell you that one of the warmest moments I have seen at CNN occurred this morning when top folks across the network gave Anderson, Sanjay and their team hearty applause for their coverage in Haiti. Their efforts there have been a proud landmark for people at CNN.

AC360 was great tonight. Also, very interesting interview with Joel Osteen. I was sort of surprised Anderson was applying his life or situation in the interview – why certain people’s fate isn’t as good as other’s and he also cited him and his brother also as another example. I read this on twitter and I thought the same – it looks as if “he was seeking religious council”. Well, sort of, for me. It seems what he has experienced in Haiti these past 2 weeks has deeply affected him. I’m quite surprised too that he’s back in the studio. I thought he’d be gone for the rest of the week. But I sure am glad he decided to come back at once, I just wasn’t into 360 Monday night – it’s never the same when there’s no AC. Also, hope they find someone to replace Erica Hill, I miss her banter with AC. Kiran’s OK, but it just wasn’t the same.

ACAnderFan said...

Surely someone in that group of missionaries knew that what they were doing was wrong. Surely they knew they needed some kind of documentation. It seems like they had no idea what they were doing. I mean they weren't even registered to run an orphanage nor are the registered as a non profit group. Sounds like they are unorganized and have no clue what they are doing.

I liked Anderson's piece in Little Haiti. I hope in the future he'll do more reporting like this. He's so good at it and there's so much just in NYC that he could report on. It'd be nice to see little reports from him every once in a while.

The thing I remembered most of Anderson's interview with Joel Osteen was when he asked why one brother makes it and the other doesn't.

The shot was back! I missed the shot. Its a good way to end the program and its always nice to see Anderon's lighter side and hear an andergiggle or two. Loved the studio crew carried that guy around. Too funny!

360 was really good last nite. Excluding the past 2 and a half weeks, this was probably the best 360 I have seen in a long time.

So happy to see Anderson back in his anchor chair. While I love While I love field Anderson and he is truly at his best in his element I also really like studio Anderson and missed that for the past two and half weeks. I love 360 from the studio, to me it seems more put together and cohesive.

Jaanza said...

I was glad to see Anderson back at work although I would have given him another day or two of vacation time. I guess it's a Nielsen month and CNN wanted him on the job.

Of course Anderson was going to start with Haiti. I don't know if the missionairies didn't know there were rules to be followed concerning taking children out of the country or they just figured the rules didn't apply to them. I'm figuring it was just stupidity on their part; organization sounds kind of mickey mouse.

Shoutouts to Joe Johns, David Gergen and Joel Osteen. It's not often we see a real theological segment on 360. The Shot of Mark and his carried-across-Manhattan story was cute and even cuter that he was carried out to the studio for an interview.

I hope Mia Lopez also sent her message to 360 or CNN so Anderson and Sanjay might see it.

Tedi B said...

Mia--very well said. That was very moving.

I thought the show was really good tonight and enjoyed the interview with Joel Osteen. I'm always so doubious of TV preachers because they tend to focus on the negative like fearing God or focusing on the devil. (or begging for money)Even though I am not a huge fan of most of them I do think Joel Osteen at least preaches a postive message and that's a good thing, in my opinion.

aries moon said...

A beautiful, heartfelt tribute to Anderson and his team from Mia Lopez and David Gergen recounting the appreciation that AC, Sanjay and crew got from the CNN staff was equally nice and well deserved.

I generally avoid tv preachers/evangelists like the plague--I don't find them especially interesting or trustworthy and I wasn't thrilled that AC was going to be speaking with the perma-smiley Osteen again, but AC searching for some sort of spiritual meaning behind the tragedies we experience in life and how to deal with them was fascinating--his time in Haiti must've impacted him in a way that he wasn't expecting--his comments about brothers and how moved he was when watching the Haitian people having a spiritual celebration of faith in the midst of the trauma were telling--I agree that it was one of the best interviews AC's done on 360, but mainly because AC seemed pretty invested in it personally. I also enjoyed AC's visit to Brooklyn and the interview with some in the Haitian community--it's nice to see him getting out of the studio and doing stories around the NY area.

John McCain did a major flip-flop on DADT but AC and Gergen went a little too easy on him, IMO.

Kieran Chetry's appearance during the 360 Bulletin was a big surprise-- she's a trouper and I hope she doesn't pass out during AM Wednesday although I know John Roberts has subbed on 360 AND anchored AM the next day.

I was watching some old AC/Erica clips and realize more than ever how much they lost when she left the show--it will be hard to replace someone who was so in tune with AC's personality/humor.

Jacq said...

Phebe, I agree 100% about the religious group in Haiti trying to move the orphans. They should have known better.

It is great to have AC back, but I felt he was a bit distracted and would rather be in Haiti (where I know his heart is). His interview with Pastor Joel was interesting, and I too was surprised that he related his own experiences. But, after what he saw in Haiti I am sure he will be forever changed emotionally and spiritually. I agree with Tedi B. about the TV preachers, but it was nice to hear a positive message.

Phebe said...

@judy, I was a bit leery of Ms. Chetry when she was hired because she came from Fox, but she has won me over. She is funny, smart and a knock out. Probably Klein's best move since he's been at CNN (or maybe second to booting Dobbs).

@pebbles, thanks for sharing David Gergen's remarks. Nice to know that AC is getting a warm welcome back.

@ACAnderfan, I agree about the street reporting. The last time he did that (abortion clinic) I thought it worked well too.

@Jaanza, I have been told by people in the ratings business that cable channels aren't involved in sweeps.
I agree with you that Mia's message needed to be seen by those and 360..... and it was passed along.

@ Tedi B., Couldn't agree with you more about TV preachers. Ted Haggard's wife has a new book out, wonder if she'll pop up on 360? AC seemed to have a target on Haggard's back for months.

@aires moon, you make a good point about JR having done 360 before and anchored AM also but Kiran juggles young children and homemaking too while Roberts is foot loose and fancy free. What is it they say about backwards and in heels? :)

@Jacq, I didn't think AC was distracted, maybe weary and a little overwhelmed by the experience of Haiti?

Jazz said...

Anderson's piece on the missionaries was great. He asked all the questions I was asking. I'm bewildered by these people. Look, before this earthquake, there were three things I knew about Haiti...voodoo, child trafficking and slavery, and floods. Did they not know that trafficking is a problem? I am one person who believes they did not have good intentions. How were they going to help these children? They didn't have an orphanage set up. All I heard was what they had planned to do. And I absolutely couldn't believe what Karl Penhaul was reporting. They had an interpreter? They were planning this for how long and saw no need to learn the language? Partially even? Didn't they say the children were saying that they had parents? They were being asked questions and they started singing hymns to avoid answering? If their intentions were good, they should be defending themselves every chance they get. How are they going to pay to get these children the supplies they needed? The help they need physically and mentally. Most of the orphanages or children shelters, I've seen on the news, take care of these children in Haiti. Did the parents who gave up their children know that these children would be taken out of country to possibly be adopted in the US? Or did they believe that their child would be taken to one of these orphanages in Haiti to be taken care of and educated? These missionaries seemed completely unprepared which, IMO, could have been very dangerous for these children. Where's the good intention in that? This story angers me to no end.

I saw Joel Olsteen and I was ready to turn. I couldn't find my remote and I'm glad I didn't. I have my opinions of TV preachers, I won't get into that, but I found Mr Olsteens words surprisingly inspirational. I too was surprised at Anderson questions? It seems he was looking for something in what Joel Olsteen was saying.
Mia Lopez's comment was beautiful. I teared up as I read it. Thank you for posting it.

Wonz said...

Tuesday night's 360 was the best "studio 360" I've seen in months! It was good to have Anderson back in the anchor chair -- and I enjoyed all the segments.

While I have a strong faith and have been very active in my local church for years, I'm not a big fan of television preachers. That being said, Anderson's interview with Joel Osteen was my favorite segment. It was quite touching in many ways and I think it's evident that the faith Anderson witnessed in the people of Haiti has had an effect on him.

I am glad to see AC360 staying with Haiti. I hope this continues.

@pebbles - thanks for sharing the David Gergen post from the 360 Live blog. It's nice to know that the "top folks across the network" acknowledged Anderson, Sanjay and their teams for their excellent reporting from Haiti.

And, I, too hope Anderson continues to do more "street" reporting.

Hat's off to Anderson and team 360 for bringing us an excellent show last night!

MichellenLomita said...

I also enjoyed the interview with Joel Osteen. I was delighted to watch this positive discussion of spiritual issues on AC360. Anderson opened a bit of his heart, and Pastor Osteen cheered and encouraged him after all the suffering AC witnessed in Haiti. I thought the rest of 360 was mediocre and slow. Don't know how CNN supposes this drab programming will hold the attention of young viewers. I'm 40s-something (lol), and I think it's boring. Way too talkative and not enough footage and visuals. But it's nice to see AC home anchoring, and his outfit was very attractive. He looks great in those colors. IMO Ms. Chetry would do fine as co-anchor. She's upbeat and professional, and she doesn't flirt.

Anonymous said...

I think Kiran was great in the studio with Anderson - if Anderson were to have a co-host again, I think she would be nice with him, and I think he likes her.

Anonymous said...

@MichellenLomita- I enjoyed AC yesterday and I'm 18...so I guess some of the younger crowd likes him :)